MaterialsTechnical Article

Ductile Iron vs Gray Iron:
Choosing the Right Grade

Gray iron and ductile iron start from similar base iron but behave very differently in service. The shape of the graphite decides strength, elongation, vibration damping and machinability, and with them the parts each iron suits.

Gray and ductile iron castings in the Longtai machining hall

The Difference Is the Graphite

In gray iron, graphite forms as flakes. The flake edges act as internal notches, so gray iron has moderate tensile strength and almost no elongation. In return it machines easily, damps vibration well and conducts heat.

Ductile iron, also called nodular or SG iron, receives a nodularizing treatment before pouring so that the graphite forms spheres. Spheres interrupt the metal far less than flakes, which gives ductile iron higher strength and measurable elongation. Our lab examines the microstructure under a metallographic microscope and reports it with micrographs.

Metallographic microscope used to examine graphite form in iron castings

Grades We Pour

Iron and standardGradeMinimum tensile strengthMinimum yield · elongationTypical parts
Gray iron, ASTM A48Class 30 · 40 · 5030 · 40 · 50 ksi (207 · 276 · 345 MPa)Not specifiedBearing housings, pedestals, discharge bodies, head plates
Gray iron for pressure parts, ASTM A278Class 4040 ksi (276 MPa)Not specifiedCylinders, cylinder covers, bearing retainers
Gray iron, GB/T 9439HT200 · HT300200 · 300 MPa130–195 · 195–260 MPa · 0.3–0.8%Motor end covers, junction boxes; machine tool bases and columns
Ductile iron, ASTM A53660-40-1860 ksi (414 MPa)40 ksi (276 MPa) · 18%Pump casings, suction plates, stuffing boxes, valve housings
Ductile iron, ASTM A53665-45-1265 ksi (448 MPa)45 ksi (310 MPa) · 12%
Ductile iron, ASTM A53680-60-0380 ksi (555 MPa)60 ksi (415 MPa) · 3%
Minimum values as specified in each standard. For GB/T 9439, yield is the 0.1% proof strength (Rp0.1), shown as the ranges listed in the standard’s annex. Typical parts are taken from our recent shipments.

When Gray Iron Is the Better Choice

  • Vibration damping: machine tool bases, columns and tables, which we cast in gray iron ASTM A48 Class 45.
  • Complex housings and covers: gray iron fills thin, intricate sections well and machines quickly, which keeps cost down on parts such as motor end bells and junction boxes.
  • Pressure-containing compressor parts: cylinders, cylinder covers and bearing retainers to ASTM A278.
  • Parts loaded mainly in compression rather than in tension or by impact.

When Ductile Iron Is the Better Choice

  • Heavy load, shock or impact: slurry pump casings and suction plates face heavy slurry loads and erosion, where ductile iron’s strength and elongation matter.
  • Thinner sections for the same load: higher strength allows lighter walls than gray iron.
  • Parts that must not fail by sudden fracture: elongation gives a margin before cracking.

Within ductile iron, 60-40-18 favors elongation and toughness, 65-45-12 balances strength and elongation, and 80-60-03 gives higher strength and hardness with lower elongation. Most slurry pump castings in our catalog are 65-45-12. Ductile iron requires nodularizing treatment and tighter process control, so it usually costs more per kilogram than gray iron.

Ductile iron slurry pump suction side casing, ASTM A536 65-45-12, 980 kg

Grade Equivalents

Drawings often cite Chinese, European or Japanese grades. The table gives approximate equivalents for reference; the standard on your drawing governs.

China · GB/TEurope · ENUSA · ASTMJapan · JIS
HT200EN-GJL-200A48 Class 30FC200
HT250EN-GJL-250A48 Class 35 / 40FC250
HT300EN-GJL-300A48 Class 45FC300
HT350EN-GJL-350A48 Class 50FC350
QT400-18EN-GJS-400-18A536 60-40-18FCD400-18
QT450-10EN-GJS-450-10A536 65-45-12FCD450-10
QT600-3EN-GJS-600-3A536 80-60-03FCD600-3

How We Verify the Grade

Every heat is analyzed on a SPECTRO optical emission spectrometer (29+ elements) before pouring. Test bars are pulled on a 30 t tensile testing machine for tensile strength and elongation, hardness is checked in HB or HRC, and metallography confirms the graphite form. Common cast iron, cast steel and stainless steel grades have been tested for physical properties by a third party. See Melting for how chemistry is controlled.

Not sure which iron suits your part? Send your drawing for engineering review. We reply within 72 hours.

Request a Quote